That Night masquerades as a thriller, but it uses the genre trappings to interrogate a sibling bond in surprising and interesting ways.

Every character in That Night is deeply flawed in some way or another, and their moments of humanity never necessarily redeem them, but instead paint a holistic, contemplative portrait of a person struggling between their morality and their love. Within this gray area is where the show hits its stride, where its capacity to enthrall using two seemingly tired thriller tropes resides.

We really had trouble connecting with the sisters and the sticky situation they get themselves into in That Night, and we don’t know if things are going to get better as we get deeper into this story.