Critic Reviews
Filter by season
77
Metascore
Generally Favorable
positive
40(82%)
mixed
9(18%)
negative
0(0%)
Showing 49 Critic Reviews
Jul 16, 2021
100
Schmigadoon! takes the mini-arc of a scene-into-song — words no longer suffice so one must explode into song — and expands it out into beautiful, staggering, slow-motion detail. It's a triumph of craft, character, and courage. It's a show I can't recommend enough, a strange bird I hope never stops singing.
Jul 16, 2021
100
Much like its Apple TV+ counterpart “Ted Lasso,” this is a series that’s optimistic and uplifting. “Schmigadoon!” is a brilliant and unique program that’s well worth your time.
Apr 4, 2023
100
It’s just the right length. Six, not eight or 10, half-hour episodes that breeze by quickly, all packed with fun. And even though it’s busy and filled with eye-candy and distractions, the series never loses sight of the central relationship. Strong and Key play their roles with just the right blend of absurdity and bemused observance.
Apr 5, 2023
100
Schmigadoon! really thrives in Season 2 with its approach to the premise. ... The true strength of the second season is how thoughtful it manages to be, even while the absurdity and comedy from the first season are still present. With Key and Strong taking the lead, it's hard for it not to.
Apr 21, 2023
100
Hard to imagine anything bringing more happiness than Schmigadoon! [24 Apr - 7 May 2023, p.6]
Apr 3, 2023
95
“Schmigadoon!” is a hoot — an inventive and thoroughly enjoyable summer delight.
Mar 31, 2023
91
While all of the returners bring their musical-theater chops, Krakowski and Tveit end up shining the most. ... The splendid scenic design and costume design bring in details that will make eagle-eyed fans squeal with glee, too. nd as for the music: After picking up an Emmy for season one’s “Corn Puddin’,” Paul once again skillfully captures the essence of the genre and time period here.
Jul 7, 2021
90
Along with Trying and Ted Lasso, Schmigadoon! is another entry into AppleTV+ cornering the market on uplifting, positive, smart TV. It may be a niche joy, but you can’t watch without smiling.
Jul 7, 2021
90
Schmigadoon! is silly, sweet, sharp, and most of all, sensational. It’s just the latest in a string of Apple TV+ comedies to balance wit and heart.
Jul 20, 2021
90
Jubilant and wonderfully clever. ... Schmigadoon! is such a delight I never wanted to leave. [19 Jul - 1 Aug 2021, p.6]
