
Critic Reviews
79
Metascore
Generally Favorable
positive
20(95%)
mixed
1(5%)
negative
0(0%)
Showing 21 Critic Reviews
Jan 2, 2026
100
The Plague isn’t a horror movie per se, but it moves with the mood and music of one.
Jan 2, 2026
100
The Plague does an exceptional job of making viewers share in Ben’s growing sense of dread.
Jan 2, 2026
91
The Plague is what remains if you strip most of the actual horror out of a horror movie, but keep the fear. The tension gets so thick you could cut it with a knife. Then it goes beyond that; you’d need something stronger, and sharper.
Dec 26, 2025
89
I’d say if The Plague wasn’t nominated for Best Original Score there’s something terribly wrong with the Oscars, but The Plague didn’t even make the short list, so there’s just something terribly wrong with the Oscars.
Jan 2, 2026
89
Like the weeping sores that spread on Eli’s body, the bloody gouges that Ben carves into his thumb with nervous scratching, and the haunted look in Daddy Wags’ eyes, Polinger delivers a troubling and heart-stopping lesson that such childhood horrors will always leave a mark.
Jan 2, 2026
88
A terrifying first film in which a tween water polo team becomes a "Lord of the Flies" metaphor for the hell of modern bullying. The scares are killer, but it’s the violence of the adolescent mind that hits hardest and haunts you longest.
Nov 5, 2025
83
This is a deeply emotional film in high concept clothing, coded to resonate with those of us well-versed in the instinct to betray ourselves in order to be accepted.
Nov 6, 2025
80
Charlie Polinger opens his thrilling and uneasy directorial debut feature The Plague with an arresting sequence that quickly establishes the haunting undertones of this adolescent psychological thriller.
Nov 5, 2025
80
The film’s relentless narrative is expertly performed by a cast of newcomer talent who empathetically portray its heavy subject matter with deliberate psychological intensity.