Marshall Shaffer
Critic Overview in Movies
68Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
135(68%)
mixed
56(28%)
negative
8(4%)
Highest Critic Score
Lowest Critic Score
16
Critic Reviews for Movies
Jul 30, 2026
Tony83
Jul 30, 2026
“Tony” remarkably manages to embrace and eschew the revisionist strain of “Great Man” biopics, which have attempted to work around cradle-to-grave formulas ripped from Wikipedia by homing in on an illustrative incident in the subject’s life. Knowing there’s more cake is not necessary for the slice to fulfill its mandate to be sufficient and satisfying. It’s plenty sweet as is.
Jun 25, 2026
jackass: best and last75
Jun 25, 2026
Even if the film consists primarily of reheated material, the cast and crew still know how to make it feel warm and welcoming.
Jun 16, 2026
Unidentified67
Jun 16, 2026
Unidentified ranks among a rare class of movies that forces viewers to re-interpret everything they’ve just seen once the full picture locks into place. Whether that makes everything that came before worthless or worth it may be less a reaction to al-Mansour’s filmmaking and more of a reflection of the audience’s own subject position.
Jun 15, 2026
In Memoriam75
Jun 15, 2026
There’s a great evisceration of Hollywood in here that gets a bit too buried until sentimental schmaltz.
Jun 12, 2026
Wasteman75
Jun 12, 2026
Cal McMau’s Wasteman illustrates why a powerful paradox about prisons makes them such a popular staging ground for psychodramas.
Jun 11, 2026
The Death of Robin Hood50
Jun 11, 2026
It’s easy enough to admire the evident technical merits, yes, but difficult to find any element that invites a viewer into the specific, soulful experience of the characters. As The Death of Robin Hood circles the obvious ending, the main point of reflection it invites is the missed opportunity to flesh out this world with a level of detail on par with its ambitions.
May 26, 2026
Pressure63
May 26, 2026
The film functions best when Anthony Maras reflects his protagonist's nature: straightforward, unflashy, and mission-driven.
May 19, 2026
The Samurai and the Prisoner63
May 19, 2026
The Samurai and the Prisoner offers a master class in framing and blocking, with Kurosawa Kiyoshi continually finding new ways to render the story’s self-contained setting as a source of rich visual pleasure.
May 16, 2026
Gentle Monster75
May 16, 2026
[Kreutzer] might have served Gentle Monster better by narrowing her focus to a pure character study. But one hardly has to squint to find those elements in the film. They’re present every time Kreutzer trains the camera on Seydoux and lets her demonstrate why she’s among cinema’s finest working actresses.
May 11, 2026
Obsession75
May 11, 2026
Obsession’s big set-piece sequences are as chilling in their effect as they are confident in their execution.