50
Neither particularly exciting nor even safe, Superstars’ greatest Sonic sin is being really quite boring, and not very suited to multiplayer antics at all. [Issue#34, p.70]
85
Sonic and friends are back in a new 2D adventure to thwart Dr. Robotnik's evil plans in Sonic Superstars! It even has multiplayer options. Is it any good? Read more about it so you can decide for yourself.
70
Sonic Superstars is a good classic 2D Sonic game that shines especially in its visuals. Stages have a wider array of gimmicks when compared to older 2D Sonic games and boss fights are much more complex. However, the game design can feel unpolished and often doesn’t do a good job in communicating with the player. While the addition of local co-op sounds great on paper, Sonic’s speedy gameplay proves to be a difficult match for it.
2
A boring, soulless cash grab that’s offensive to Sonic players everywhere. I’ve been with the blue mascot since its inception for the Genesis and was looking forward to this game made by the Sonic mania team (that’s an incredible game) but this game has tedious boss fights, absolutely no audio feedback from the hero, terrible (and I mean TERRIBLE) multiplayer with no explanation on what to do or how to do it, just hard pass on this one. I had it on my back shelf thinking I hadn’t played it and popped it in today just to see that I had beaten the main story (that’s how completely forgettable this game truly is. Sega, do better, don’t offend your fan base with this obvious cash grab that was released as a full priced title. Hard (HARD) pass. Only reason it gets a 2 was because of the great visuals, that’s the only thing this has got going for it because even the audio and music are on the back end. Skip this one at all costs, this is Sonic 4 levels of bad, but not Sonic 06 levels of catastrophe, just plain old forgettable and soulless
4
This was one of the weaker sonic games levels drag on for too long and some of the bosses were extremely tedious. None of the stages really stood out either compared to sonic mania which even that game had issues for me the levels were better paced in that game and boss fights were faster and more enjoyable. Trips campaign is extremely unfair with enemies everywhere and spikes all over the level. The last couple of bosses are long tedious gauntlets with insta death attacks. Sonic Superstars is a mediocre game that you are better skipping even Forces was more enjoyable. Don't buy this game it's very bad.
7
At least is not bad but is not really good. Whoever has created the destroy 100 enemies with “character” special ability achievement has passed 11 years in economic downfall. But the game itself is meh. Is not bad is good but I’m not convinced this game is REALLY good. When you stand like 2 cm away from your TV or Monitor you clearly see Sonic is pixelated. However is not a bad game.
Sonic Superstars
Released On:
Oct 17, 2023
Metascore
Mixed or Average
73
User score
Generally Favorable
8.2
My Score
Drag or tap to give a rating
Hover and click to give a rating
Where to Buy
Metascore
Mixed or Average
73
49% Positive
32 Reviews
32 Reviews
51% Mixed
33 Reviews
33 Reviews
0% Negative
0 Reviews
0 Reviews
Oct 17, 2023
91
There are many hours of play in Sonic Superstars and whether you play mostly single-player like me, or co-op, there is fun for every Sonic fan and I feel the fans will be happy with this one. Even with Super Mario Bros. Wonder around the corner it’s going to be a great gaming holiday season for platformer fans. Sonic Superstars comes highly recommended.
Oct 16, 2023
85
Sonic Superstars is not only one of the greatest tributes to the more classic side of the blue hedgehog, but a game with a character and personality all of its own. A title that feels familiar from the first moment, but that will surprise us as we progress. SEGA proves that there is life for classic Sonic beyond the pixel art style.
User score
Generally Favorable
8.2
74% Positive
618 Ratings
618 Ratings
17% Mixed
145 Ratings
145 Ratings
9% Negative
72 Ratings
72 Ratings
Nov 26, 2025
10
It's really really better than super mario wonder.sonic superstars has emerald power,5 playable characters,3 stories.this game has to be one the best platformer games!
Jun 9, 2025
10
It's a very good game and I enjoyed it thoroughly, can't wait to see what else is in store too... Keep it up, Sega.
Oct 13, 2023
80
If Sonic Superstars is the future of the franchise, then it's bright enough that the blue hedgehog will have to wear shades.
Nov 10, 2023
70
Sonic Superstars is a good classic 2D Sonic game that shines especially in its visuals. Stages have a wider array of gimmicks when compared to older 2D Sonic games and boss fights are much more complex. However, the game design can feel unpolished and often doesn’t do a good job in communicating with the player. While the addition of local co-op sounds great on paper, Sonic’s speedy gameplay proves to be a difficult match for it.
Oct 17, 2023
70
Sonic Superstars shines brightest when it’s sticking to what made the Genesis titles so successful. Running through the levels, launching oneself off spring boards and dashing through loop the loops is just as enjoyable now as it was in the 16-bit days. Cracks in this Chaos Emerald become more apparent with some of the changes. Many of the boss designs are good, but the patterned approach to fighting them can make them excessively drag on. The powers granted by Chaos Emeralds are fun additions, but the overall emphasis on exploration over speed takes away from the core experience of what one expects and loves from a Sonic game, plus the addition of multiplayer is a reminder of why these have traditionally been single player experiences. But criticisms aside it’s still a fun game, and while far from flawless, still a must play for fans of classic Sonic games.
Oct 31, 2023
60
Sonic Superstars embodies the classic 2D Sonic game qualities, which is a commendable feature as it ensures an enjoyable gaming experience. However, this also serves as a point of critique, given the series' frequent reliance on nostalgia in past iterations.
Oct 13, 2023
50
Sonic Superstars started so well and with such potential but quickly fell off a cliff due to its irritating Zone design, forgettable soundtrack and odd aesthetic choices.
Oct 27, 2024
10
This game holds a special place in my heart because it’s a game that my best friend and I play every single Friday. It’s become a tradition at this point. We make chili dogs then play Sonic Superstars!
Jan 4, 2026
7
At least is not bad but is not really good. Whoever has created the destroy 100 enemies with “character” special ability achievement has passed 11 years in economic downfall. But the game itself is meh. Is not bad is good but I’m not convinced this game is REALLY good. When you stand like 2 cm away from your TV or Monitor you clearly see Sonic is pixelated. However is not a bad game.
Sep 27, 2025
7
Buen juego: Buen diseño en los niveles pero poco arriesgado, con mecánicas interesantes como las esmeraldas, pero que nunca son aprovechadas sino hasta que el juego nos las indique. Problemas de balance en la dificultad en las distintas zonas y sobre todo los jefes absolutamente desbalanceados y terribles: o son ridículamente fáciles o injustos hasta la medula. La banda sonora es buena en su mayoría, pero hay temas definitivamente horribles que son difíciles de quitarte de la cabeza. El arte y los gráficos son muy lindos, pero las animaciones 3D de los personajes no son ni la mitad de carismáticas como sus contrapartes 2D. Lo recomendaría fácilmente sino fuera por sus grandes problemas con la dificultad, eso lo hace difícil de recomendar. Plataforma: Nintendo Switch, Fecha: 27/9/25, Hora de publicacion: 7:44AM CST.
Apr 21, 2026
4
This was one of the weaker sonic games levels drag on for too long and some of the bosses were extremely tedious. None of the stages really stood out either compared to sonic mania which even that game had issues for me the levels were better paced in that game and boss fights were faster and more enjoyable. Trips campaign is extremely unfair with enemies everywhere and spikes all over the level. The last couple of bosses are long tedious gauntlets with insta death attacks. Sonic Superstars is a mediocre game that you are better skipping even Forces was more enjoyable. Don't buy this game it's very bad.
SummaryAdventure through the mystical Northstar Islands in this all-new take on classic 2D Sonic high-speed action platforming. Play as Sonic, Tails, Knuckles, and Amy Rose and harness all-new Emerald powers to move and attack in dynamic new ways. Navigate gorgeous, never-before-seen environments solo or with up to 3 other players and stop ... Read More
Rated Efor Everyone
Platforms:
- PlayStation 5
- Xbox Series X
- PC
- PlayStation 4
- Xbox One
- Nintendo Switch
Initial Release Date:Oct 17, 2023
Developer:
- Arzest
Publisher:
