Alison Herman
Critic Overview in TV Shows
63Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
135(53%)
mixed
99(39%)
negative
23(9%)
Highest Critic Score
Lowest Critic Score
Critic Reviews for TV Shows
Oct 1, 2026
East of Eden (2026): Season 180
Oct 1, 2026
I wasn’t totally convinced a narrative so dependent on the passage of time was an organic fit for the screen. (Pugh gets aged up with cosmetics, but Abbott looks as boyish as ever while Adam attempts to act as patriarch.) Still, the endeavor feels worth it for Pugh and Lee’s standout efforts, which etch their characters deep into one’s memory.
Sep 23, 2026
Brothers (2026): Season 140
Sep 23, 2026
“Brothers” has eyes for only one central relationship, and every second spent on satellite pairings sags with infectious boredom.
Sep 23, 2026
Wonka's The Golden Ticket: Season 120
Sep 23, 2026
The AI Wilder isn’t the only instance of the contemporary and the retro colliding in unpleasantly discordant ways. Challenges are introduced with “Fallout”-style, ‘50s-esque videos that are aesthetically out of place. .... The device [AI Wilder] grows especially chilling when tasked with delivering jokes, or rather, humor-scented snippets of dialogue that lack a human’s je ne sais quoi.
Sep 15, 2026
The Primetime Emmy Awards: Season 7640
Sep 15, 2026
Drab is drab. Whatever the justifications, the 76th Emmys were a far less dynamic and more stilted watch than the January show.
Sep 15, 2026
Neagley: Season 140
Sep 15, 2026
While Sten performs capably in the (sporadic, perfunctory) action scenes, her taciturn protagonist declaring that “I don’t have trauma” can’t reverse psychology the viewer into genuine curiosity. That’s because Neagley is a collection of hard-surface, soft-heart tropes that never achieve independent momentum.
Sep 9, 2026
The Drop: A Snowfall Saga: Season 160
Sep 9, 2026
If “The Drop” can get its plot to the level of its immersive production, it’ll be something to see.
Sep 8, 2026
DANG!: Season 170
Sep 8, 2026
Many new comedies these days suffer from a compressed run that offers little room to riff and experiment. By keeping a tight focus on its nuclear unit, “Dang!” avoids this issue with a compact concept that never feels too big for its vessel.
Sep 4, 2026
Earle Meets World: Season 130
Sep 4, 2026
Conflicts are too far from the broader human experience to engender much sympathy, yet too petty to take on a sheen of aspirational glamor. Nor are they negotiated with any Housewife-ian flair for drama. The Earles often sound like wooden actors reading from a prefabricated script, possibly because they are.
Aug 27, 2026
Adults: Season 280
Aug 27, 2026
“Adults” finally has its own momentum, largely generated by a cast whose rapport obviates the need for any sweeping statements about their generation.
Aug 14, 2026
Lanterns: Season 160
Aug 14, 2026
Not only is the show overt about its influences to the point where it can’t transcend them; it’s also a mix of shoe-leather investigation and glowing green lasers that never stops clashing. .... At least there’s never long to wait until Chandler and Pierre are once again trading barbs, the place where “Lanterns” is most palpably in its preferred groove.