Two successful guys in their 30's have their lives turned upside down when their nightmare dads unexpectedly move in.

Eli and Warner fight over the same woman.

Eli gets serious with a funny girl.

The doctor is in.

The dads try to prove that they've still got it.

When David accidentally brings bedbugs into the house, he and Eli are forced to sleep at Ghost Child Games. Meanwhile, Camilla gets the lead in a local play and Crawford ends up being uncharacteristically helpful.

Eli begins to doubt his and Warner's friendship when Warner decides to let Camilla be his partner in their annual Virtual Tennis Tournament. Meanwhile, Crawford and David try to prove that they can make true friends.

An angry programmer sabotages Ghost Child's new Christmas-themed game with offensive content, and David gets a job as a Santa Claus.

When Edna faces deportation for being an illegal immigrant, Eli forces David to marry her, but soon comes to regret it when Edna gets too much into the role of wife and mother.

Eli takes care of Veronica when she gets sick, hoping his kindness will lead to them sleeping together.

Eli is bullied by his new girlfriend's 12-year-old son, and Warner picks a fake fight with Camilla so he can sleep on the more comfortable couch.

Warner gets an unusual proposition from an ex-girlfriend while his wife is away, and Crawford and David pose as a gay couple to get free perks from a hotel.

Eli and Warner work with a mobster.

When Crawford gets too drunk and accidentally ruins the Whittemores' couch, Camilla insists that they all quit drinking so much.

Eli ignores David's constant complaining, and one of them ends up in the hospital.

The gang helps David plan his fake funeral, while Eli is still moping over Veronica being engaged.