The return of a kids' TV show from the 1980s coincides with the disappearance of a young child.

Mike must convince Gary that Candle Cove is behind the murders; Marla, Jessica, and Amy frantically search for Mike.

Mike's daughter Lily mysteriously arrives in Iron Hill, leading to more information about the murders of 1988; Mike and Jessica take drastic measures to heal the past and protect Lily from Candle Cove.

Mike and Amy learn that the creator of Candle Cove isn't who they think; A brutal crime shocks the Iron Hill police force.

After Lily is taken by Candle Cove, Mike puts himself in danger to save her and confront his tormentor; Marla faces an impossible choice.