WaterBottle37

Definitely the weakest in the GTA trilogy. Doesn't stand well against the test of time. Some times I felt like I was forcing myself to play through some parts, but the story of the protagonist doing anything to get closer to revenge seemed nice, but the characters had very little depth, especially the main character who doesn't speak at all. A decent game, that's not so big in the replayability factor

Loved every aspect of it, especially the vibe, driving around in vice city felt so nice compared to any other game in the trilogy. Story following Tommy going from tracking his money to owning Vice city with the final showdown with the Mafia was peak. I feel it was rushed compared to San Andreas that has a lot of other cool game mechanics. But that didn't matter very much as I am a bit biased by nostalgia, because of this being my first GTA game and stuff

It was a very fun game when I played it as a kid. I have probably completed it around thrice at least. The game mechanics like being able to dual wield any weapon, or the unusual supers that you had, or the adrenaline bar that makes everything go slow-mo, and the rewinds that go back a few seconds if you die or on command, were all very unique. But some cons are the vibe didn't really hit, and it was a very linear story that is disguised as an open world game, there are little to no aspects of open world in this game. But even apart from all that it is a very fun game indeed

I would say its a bit over hated. A good game, just a bit more difficult, contains places where you learn what to do over repetitive attempts. The voiceover, the music made this an enjoyable experience overall. Would I recommend it? Probably not. For some people, there's probably more fun and rewarding games that they would rather play, but would I play it again? Yeah

Gameplay, way ahead of its time. I played this in 2026 and I never for a second felt it as an 'old' game. With the free flow combat all the fights felt amazing. The lack of open world didn't feel like that big of a flaw, It was a wonderful execution of a linear game, the way it blocks of certain parts once you are done with them, then gives you new gadgets to get back there, was all too good. All the different types of bosses with their own different fight like Scarecrow's world, escaping killer croc, the bane fight, each of them were unique and very well designed

I'll agree some missions were annoying, but when there's a 100 missions 1 or 2 are bound to not be as good as the others. My god though, what a game, loved the shifting from city to city, and how the nature of the missions change from one city to another. Each city had a different vibe that you could feel, Los Santos having a hood vibe, San Fierro with the vibe similar to liberty city from gta 3, with all the mafia type missions, and one of my favorite character Woozie, the jokes were too funny. And the final Vegas vibe from Las Venturas, with the casino heist were all flawlessly executed. Not to mention all the game mechanics with character customization that was ahead of its time, being able to change your fighting style, the list goes on. It's hard to think of a flaw I found in this game

Loved every bit of it, from the characters, to the jokes, to the music and the way characters know about your save file and change their interactions accordingly. I never expected that I'd tear up over a bunch of pixels. A game that made me speechless, just had me sitting there once I finished it. That being said, some of the few cons are, there are parts of it that feel not just scary but disturbing, so much so that I couldn't play it alone. Gameplay wise some things that you had to do to get the good ending seemed a bit forced, most of them were funny, but somethings where you had to go out of your way, to do some of the "side-quests" got a bit annoying but the good ending was definitely worth it. The fights in pacifist route, where you had to defeat the monsters without fighting and acting were also really fun. Overall a very enjoyable experience, would definitely recommend. This is a game that's objectively a 10, but just felt some things didn't hit for me and thus a 9/10

Loved playing the game. The art style, difficulty, gameplay were absolutely fantastic. The only reason I'm not giving it a 10 is because some bosses had weird hitboxes that kills you randomly that frustrates you, but in general it's not a "AHH THIS GAME IS SO HARD I HATE IT" kinda game, it was an enjoyable experience