User Reviews
Filter by season and episode
5.4
User score
Mixed or Average
positive
8(44%)
mixed
3(17%)
negative
7(39%)
Showing 5 User Reviews
Jun 21, 2020
3
Yawn. We watch both Project Runway (with the new hosts) and Making the Cut, and Project Runway is far more interesting. Heidi and Tim are annoying, their skits are a bore (stick to fashion) and the show lacks suspense. Auf wiedersehen ("a-vee-de-sen")
Jun 1, 2020
3
I was so disappointed. I love Tim and Heidi but the contestants were meh I couldn't warm up to any of them except Meagan. Other than the Joseph I didn't see that Naomi et al had any idea what women who could afford the clothes would want. It seemed like a contest between widow's weeds and biker gone soft and anything black. Boring!!
Apr 26, 2020
1
Just because Tim and Heidi are given a ton more money to make this show than they had for Project Runway, it doesn't make this a better show. It's just a lot of great locations and bad "bits" featuring the comedy styles of Tim and Heidi - which always fall flat. We just don't care much about any of the contestants in the series like we did with PR. The fact that they are already established designers also takes away the stakes. Watching a bunch of veritable newbies and the chemistry/drama in the work room really made PR work. This is just a lesser, glossy facsimile.
Apr 10, 2020
10
I love this show ! The format is great and exciting, the contestants are great, and what I appreciate the most is seeing the kindness and support between them. There's no cattiness and crazy egos. The judges are all fantastic a great combo, and I appreciate Naomi Campbell the most as she brings great gravitas and straight to the point opinions. Nicole Richie is always a little firecracker, my second favourite. I didn't like how Carine Roitfeld and Nicole weren't in Tokyo and they introduced a new judge. I don't watch reality shows but this is definitely great !
Mar 31, 2020
7
I am enjoying this new format quite a bit. What I don't like as much is the fake banter between Heidi & Tim. Heidi danced with dancers on some stage. And she gushed, Tim how did you organize this? Tim didn't, the show produced that bit, not Tim. Also, Heidi is way too enthusiastic, calm down a bit and get back to the designers.
