Sheila O'Malley
Critic Overview in Movies
71Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
469(77%)
mixed
69(11%)
negative
72(12%)
Highest Critic Score
100
Lowest Critic Score
Critic Reviews for Movies
Jun 12, 2026
O Horizon38
Jun 12, 2026
Written and directed by Madeleine Rotzler, the film is a general wash of generalized muted feeling, where nothing coheres because nothing sharpens into focus.
Jun 5, 2026
Carolina Caroline88
Jun 5, 2026
One could also imagine a version of “Carolina Caroline” told as an “homage” to crime-spree movie tropes, with all the style and no substance. We’ve all seen that movie a hundred times. Rehmeier, though, cares about individuality, and he has a sense of humor. He doesn’t force chemistry, but he leaves lots of space for it.
May 29, 2026
The Currents75
May 29, 2026
Mumenthaler’s oblique off-center approach makes “Currents” a strangely mesmerizing work, and up until almost the very end, its mysteries remain intact.
May 15, 2026
Forge75
May 15, 2026
Forge isn’t perfect, and some of the storylines don’t stick the landing, but Ng has created a space where all of these ideas are at play simultaneously, where we see characters we haven’t seen before, operating in new and surprising contexts.
Apr 10, 2026
Hamlet75
Apr 10, 2026
The film has atmosphere and energy as well as a specific point of view.
Apr 3, 2026
Living the Land88
Apr 3, 2026
The tensions in “Living the Land” are experienced in a bittersweet key. We are looking at Atlantis. The film is deeply mournful, but also pierced with joy.
Mar 27, 2026
Holy Days50
Mar 27, 2026
There’s strong emotion in “Holy Days,” but it results entirely from the talented cast. The story’s structure is so phony and over-determined that there is no real suspense, and, even more deadly, the tone is artificially “comedic.” True moments of unfettered humor are nowhere to be seen.
Mar 20, 2026
Tow75
Mar 20, 2026
In less deft hands, the film could have been a clichéd affair, featuring Amanda delivering an impassioned courtroom speech that brings the judge to tears and the onlookers to a burst of applause. “Tow”’s distinct tone avoids these clichés—the film is often quite funny—turning the expected into the unexpected.
Mar 6, 2026
Pompei: Below the Clouds100
Mar 6, 2026
Vesuvius might erupt again. The angel of history keeps moving forward. Time destroys, preserves, and then returns (one hopes, at least). Rosi’s film is a meditative and moving document showing that process and possibility.
Feb 27, 2026
EPiC: Elvis Presley in Concert88
Feb 27, 2026
EPiC is so vivid it makes Elvis seem not like an entertainer from the past, but a figure who lives in the perpetual Right Now.