Gerard Gilbert
Critic Overview in TV Shows
72Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
45(58%)
mixed
32(42%)
negative
0(0%)
Highest Critic Score
Lowest Critic Score
Critic Reviews for TV Shows
Apr 20, 2026
The Island (2025): Season 160
Apr 20, 2026
The drama itself is distinctly average, however. Nothing to write a postcard home about.
Mar 9, 2026
Malpractice: Season 280
Mar 9, 2026
Writer Grace Ofori-Attah, who worked in the NHS for 10 years, once again gives the proceedings an air of authenticity without overloading it with the sort of endless abbreviations that eventually made Line of Duty a bit of a joke.
Jan 20, 2026
After the Flood: Season 280
Jan 20, 2026
While Jo is no Catherine Cawood (Sarah Lancashire’s inimitable character in Happy Valley), neither is she meant to be. Mackie, however, is shaping up to be a villain every bit as skin-crawling as James Norton’s Tommy Lee Royce.
Jan 2, 2026
The Night Manager: Season 260
Jan 2, 2026
This new cocktail of le Carré and Bond left me slightly shaken, but not stirred.
Nov 24, 2025
Nightsleeper: Season 180
Nov 24, 2025
I came to Nightsleeper with low expectations – the bare synopsis sounded unimaginatively generic. But this promises to be an intricately constructed, high-speed ride – let’s just hope it doesn’t get stuck at a red signal sometime around episode four.
Oct 27, 2025
Trigger Point: Season 360
Oct 27, 2025
Lana herself is never in any real danger, which somewhat dampens any sense of jeopardy.
Oct 21, 2025
The Forsytes: Season 140
Oct 21, 2025
The Forsytes is about as subtle as a migraine. However, if this ruthlessly efficient scene-setter hasn’t insulted your intelligence, it may dig its soapy hooks into you. Or it might just tempt you to look at Galsworthy’s source novels to discover why this saga won him the Nobel Prize for Literature.
Oct 8, 2025
Murder Before Evensong: Season 160
Oct 8, 2025
Murder Before Evensong joins the ranks of Father Brown, Sister Boniface Mysteries and Grantchester. Unlike its bedfellows, however, this series is not purely escapist and Coles has used the generic framework of cosy crime for his own, more personal purposes. Without Amanda Redman’s Audrey, however, it would be as dry as a Communion wafer.
Sep 29, 2025
Blue Lights: Season 380
Sep 29, 2025
Blue Lights might settle into being just another standard police procedural. In the meantime, however, it remains the best cop show on British TV.
Aug 25, 2025
Brian and Maggie: Season 180
Aug 25, 2025
Walter certainly delivers a more rounded Thatcher than we’re used to, although any 80s nostalgia is limited to the lost art of the unspun, in-depth political interview. Brian and Maggie illustrates the kind of political interview (not to mention honesty) of which we are we’re being deprived.