Janju

Unbelievable how bad this show is. Teela looks like a man now. She has the classic personality disorder haircut that implies that she is not into men. Poor Dialoges, Poor Character Design, Nothing makes Sense, Teelas reactions especially make no sense. This is cultural vandalism like Terminator Dark Fate, Disney Star Wars Trilogy and so on. This show is done be people who hate He-Man and the Masters of the Universe. I don't understand how something like this can still be made.

The core problem of this show is that Beckett Mariner as the protagonist of this show has a sporty dark triad personality mixed with some random silliness and anti authority behavior. So she is a little bit like Burnham mixed with Tilly from discovery, if you want to say this nicer you could say she is like Han Solo from Star Wars. In my humble opinion the sheer amount of insubordination by Beckett clearly shows that she is unfit to be a starfleet officer in the TNG era and that is ruining the show. Especially since in my opinion Star Trek shows should not have a main protagonist and instead be an assemble show. Having the most anti-star trek character in a show be the main character of a star trek show is a very questionable decision. I also really have a problem with the portrayal of black woman by secret hideout. This is the second show with a black female lead that suffers from lack of values, mental health problems and personality disorder. The first episode is ok, the second episode a catastrophe, the third one is good and the forth one is excellent. How nerds are treated in this show also lets you question the sanity of the writing staff given the main star trek audience. For example in Episode 3 before the opening credits Beckett nerdshames Brad in front of his audience while he does an nerdy musical dance performance. This is like the 10th instance in which Brad is bullied by Beckett. Take a close look at the face from Brad while he is lead around in a headlock by Beckett at the end of episode 1. This is textbook bulling 101. If you don't understand this, please go to wikipedia and read the article about bulling. There seem to be a lot of people who don't understand what is the difference between ribbing, bulling and conflict. The show doesn't stick enough to canon, protocol is too often ignored, there is a lack of decency and overall a lot of stuff is badly done. Still, going forward, if there are more episodes like episode 4 then this will be the best star trek show produced by secret hideout by far.

I love the show. Yes it's very cheesy and it's not super logical. Stargirls hero journey starts a little weird, BUT you can see with how much love this show is made. For me this is the best super hero show from the cw after Legends of Tomorrow. This show almost feels like a movie. Great Special Effects and combat choreography. I like these almost "Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon" slow jumps and wireworks combats. A lot of great hand and footwork. Great work with the staff. To sum this up: High production value and I love it. Also, no compromise on use of characters in any way. For a fan of course there are a lot of compromises going on compared to the source material, but you have to consider when the comics have been made.