Becky Freeley returns to her Alma mater as a guidance counselor after having finally conquered the awkward, traumatic world of high school.

A handsome sub makes eyes at Becky, but she worries that he may cost another teacher his job.

Becky is troubled by a blog focusing on gossip about the school, particularly when she finds herself ranked far behind Lisa Germain on the blog's list of "most doable teachers."

Becky directs the school production of "Miss Saigon" but fears that her job will be at risk due to budget and casting problems.

Becky's advice to Lisa backfires by prompting Lisa to ask Tim for a date; meanwhile, Principal Huffy is sick, and Bruce eagerly takes over his office.