79
The levels are creative and artistic direction is solid, but the actual gameplay suffers from a lack of diversity and being clumped into big chunks.
82
All in all it's a decent game with only a few nagging issues to prevent it from being great. Comparatively, I think that the original did it better, but Spicy Horse has done a respectable job with the sequel.
70
Had Madness Returns cut its length by half and tossed in a few more gameplay mechanics, it could have easily been one of the best titles released this year.
5
This game is a great game. The story. The creativity and the artistic direction. However, I can't even finish chapter1 because of the stupid umbrella control. I press so many time lt+a but it just didn't appear sometimes. I don't know is it only problem on xbox series or is it just my problem. This made me so frustrated.
10
Personalmente este juego es especial para mi por la historia y la trama, así como el arte, por dicho motivo como me tocó en fibras sensibles le doy un 10, pero siendo completamente neutral y fría, le daría entre 7.7 y 8.3, el motivo es que el gameplay y las interacciones son un poco límitadas, y al menos en PC hay algunos bugs para acceder a ciertas zonas, tambien siento que es muy lineal y no deja explorar el resto de zonas, entiendo que el presupuesto fuese relativamente limitado así como hay que tomar en cuenta el tiempo en que fue elaborado, pero creo que es muy líneal, y entiendo que justamente es para concentrar al jugador en el fuerte del juego, que en este caso viene siendo la historia y la trama (la cual repito, al menos a mi parecer, aunque se pudo abordar mejor, es buena) pero tambien tiene otro fuerte que pudieron explotar mejor, que es al arte, los diseños de escenarios, personajes, etc... y hubiera sido maravilloso al menos en lo personal que pudiese interactuar más con otros personajes y con los escenarios y sus elementos, anyway...
10
Alice: Madness Returns é o meu jogo favorito da era Xbox 360. Artisticamente perfeito e, estranhamente, relaxante e atraente com cenários criados da mente violenta e distorcida da amável Alice Liddell. Um prato cheio pra quem ama a estética 'Dark Fantasy'.
Alice: Madness Returns
Released On:
Jun 14, 2011
Metascore
Mixed or Average
70
User score
Generally Favorable
8.2
My Score
Drag or tap to give a rating
Hover and click to give a rating
Metascore
Mixed or Average
70
43% Positive
29 Reviews
29 Reviews
55% Mixed
37 Reviews
37 Reviews
1% Negative
1 Review
1 Review
Jun 14, 2011
92
Alice: Madness Returns reminds me a lot of classic N64 platformers like Mario 64 and Banjo Kazooie in the best of ways. By mixing a dark reimagining of a literary classic with stylish combat and rock-solid platforming, EA and Spicy Horse have created a gaming experience quite unlike any other. At any rate, its miles better than the lacklustre Tim Burton movie released last year. This is one rabbit hole worth tumbling down.
Jul 1, 2011
80
A wonderfully realised fantasy world that is equal parts entrancing and disturbing. The story is well realised and will keep you enamoured until the credits roll. There are a few niggles here but nothing to stop Alice: Madness Returns from being a wonderfully different slice of entertainment. Now who's for tea?
User score
Generally Favorable
8.2
73% Positive
294 Ratings
294 Ratings
22% Mixed
89 Ratings
89 Ratings
4% Negative
18 Ratings
18 Ratings
Mar 31, 2026
10
Personalmente este juego es especial para mi por la historia y la trama, así como el arte, por dicho motivo como me tocó en fibras sensibles le doy un 10, pero siendo completamente neutral y fría, le daría entre 7.7 y 8.3, el motivo es que el gameplay y las interacciones son un poco límitadas, y al menos en PC hay algunos bugs para acceder a ciertas zonas, tambien siento que es muy lineal y no deja explorar el resto de zonas, entiendo que el presupuesto fuese relativamente limitado así como hay que tomar en cuenta el tiempo en que fue elaborado, pero creo que es muy líneal, y entiendo que justamente es para concentrar al jugador en el fuerte del juego, que en este caso viene siendo la historia y la trama (la cual repito, al menos a mi parecer, aunque se pudo abordar mejor, es buena) pero tambien tiene otro fuerte que pudieron explotar mejor, que es al arte, los diseños de escenarios, personajes, etc... y hubiera sido maravilloso al menos en lo personal que pudiese interactuar más con otros personajes y con los escenarios y sus elementos, anyway...
Mar 24, 2026
10
Alice: Madness Returns é o meu jogo favorito da era Xbox 360. Artisticamente perfeito e, estranhamente, relaxante e atraente com cenários criados da mente violenta e distorcida da amável Alice Liddell. Um prato cheio pra quem ama a estética 'Dark Fantasy'.
Jun 20, 2011
78
For the most part though, Alice: Madness Returns bazaar setting and imaginative design does a great job of immersing you, and whilst the repetition can grate slightly, its still a unique experience that is well worth your time.
Jul 4, 2011
70
Wonderland itself, the way it changes visually and the way it changes Alice, is the game's most important feature.
Jun 14, 2011
70
I'd have liked the adventure to have been trimmed of fat, the combat is at times extremely irritating, and the art design far exceeds the technical prowess on show, but at its core Alice: Madness Returns is an imaginative romp through a world that's clearly been designed by some incredibly creative minds.
Jul 10, 2011
60
I did not regret playing Madness Returns, nor could I earnestly recommend it. There's incentive to brave a secondary play through to obtain more unlockables – by way of memories and opening up new nooks by shooting pig snouts, naturally – but the problem is thus: we've been blessed – daresay spoilt – by better action/adventure titles over the past few years for Madness Returns to ever compete. Hopefully we see Alice again. I sensed a great game in Madness Returns and occasionally played one but this spicy gift horse would be best looked in the mouth.
Jun 21, 2011
40
Outdated action platformer that despite all its talk of madness is far too mundane in both design and visuals to justify its mammoth playing time.
Feb 8, 2026
10
One of my favorite games by Electronic Arts and Spicy Horse.This game is pure gold. I wanted to get that game on disc someday. This game is pure masterpeice
Oct 22, 2025
7
I finished Alice: Madness Returns as one of the picks in the Game Pass Game Club as a Spooktober themed pick. It definitely had a dark tone to fit that theme, with a story based around abusive mistreatment from Alice’s physiologist as she goes back and forth from Wonderland to dealing with the death of her family.This is a Xbox 360 era game so it shows its age now, with the platforming being finicky with easy to miss jumps and annoying invisible platforms. The combat is pretty basic but the camera sometimes fights against you. But the levels have a lot of variety and were interesting with a few jumping over to other side scrolling genres. Overall the story, the Alice in Wonderland characters and levels made up for the flaws enough to keep this one interesting enough to keep going to the end.
Oct 24, 2024
7
A dark version of Alice in wonderland. Well it’s an old game with graphics that are not great. Still, it’s a great experience with little glitches and with a twist in the story. Descent length in story and a hack and slash action adventure game.
Sep 4, 2023
4
Look, I can see why people praise this game. The imagery, aesthetics, atmosphere, puzzles, weapon variety and a creepy take on Alice's tale. Supposedly, it's all there but... it's definitely not for me. I enjoyed the first level of this game and that's it. I didn't have fun at all with everything else. Combat is annoying, puzzles are tiresome, music feels superficial, platforming goes on forever and the story just isn't well told. I liked the ending, but the road towards it was the worst. What absolutely killed this game was how tedious it is. Levels are unnecessarily HUGE, padded and bloated. Combat may have some cool weapons, but fighting is boring as hell. Not to mention the excessive use of the same puzzles, gimmicks, platforming tricks etc over and over again. Alice Madness Returns, in my experience, is a game that takes forever and amounts to nothing. It's better than the first one, yes, but that doesn't mean much. A waste of time, after all.
Feb 22, 2014
4
What could've been a nostalgic nod to early platformers instead deliquesced into a heinously psychedelic video game with solid fighting mechanics going for it and nothing else. The first hour is worthy enough; I mean, jumping around from toadstool to toadstool is entertaining enough, I will give it that. But it slowly becomes an absurd chore and some of the creatures really are monstrous.
SummaryAmerican McGee's Alice returns, with his own brand of creepy supernatural Victoriana.
Rated Mfor Mature
Platforms:
- PC
- PlayStation 3
- Xbox 360
Initial Release Date:Jun 14, 2011
Developer:
- Spicy Horse
Publisher:
