Jake is seeing two girls, Bethany and Michelle, and his friends see his fear of commitment is because he's still not over Annie. So he gets rid of everything that reminds him of Annie. Then Annie arrives at his door.

To avoid awkwardness, Naomi fires Nugget and Adrian fires Tanya, but then Patrick hires her to eat cupcakes in his bakery's window. Meanwhile, Jake's client Laura suggests she and Jake mourn their break-ups together.