93
MLB 09: The Show was a great Next Gen restart for the franchise, and MLB 10: The Show delivers nicely on that promise.
95
No baseball game has come close to delivering a complete package like this game does.
90
While the game is not perfect it is a far sight better than previous iterations. Years ago there was a MVP baseball game on the PC that was top-drawer (IMO) and MLB 10 rivals, if not exceeds, that. Top to bottom, this is an entertaining game to look at and play.
10
I have to simply say this. This game was one of the greatest gaming presentations I have ever seen for a sports game, from the audio, the bat cracking sounds, the crowd booing you in their state, and even the commentary team as they react heavily towards your play, making villain decisions that can piss them off hard. I could go about the many other features that are in the game such as in game highlights, stat overlays and replays, and visually, could see players react realistically. For my final verdict: MLB 10: The Show was and still is a fantastic video game that successfully replicated everything that you and I love about baseball. If I could pick a PS3 sports game to play for the rest of my life, I’d be more than satisfied with this game. Best gameplay, best franchise depth, and best presentation, help deliver us one of the greatest sports video games of all time. This game transports you to a era where Sony was aiming to surpass Microsoft’s Xbox 360 and destroy 2K by releasing the best possible exclusive MLB year after year, and it was not just a great baseball game for PS3, not just the best sports game for the console, but one of the BEST PlayStation 3 games of all time in general. That statement is why I give MLB 10 a fitting rating of a 10 out of 10! Just a masterpiece that Sony can’t top ever again.
9
Solid game and it's really fun to play franchise mode. It's hard to hit at times if you don't have a stacked team.
10
Last original game with legend teams, sadly this has been taken out of the newer games until much more recently and for that reason it adds a lot more depth then the games from 2011 to 2018 in my opinion
MLB 10: The Show
Released On:
Mar 2, 2010
Metascore
Universal Acclaim
91
User score
Mixed or Average
7.1
My Score
Drag or tap to give a rating
Hover and click to give a rating
All Platforms
Metascore
Universal Acclaim
100% Positive
33 Reviews
33 Reviews
0% Mixed
0 Reviews
0 Reviews
0% Negative
0 Reviews
0 Reviews
100
That commitment is made palatable by the quality oozing out of every feature, every visual detail, every pitch, and every hit in The Show--the best baseball game currently available. [Jun 2010, p.74]
95
Although it may not take the crown from the likes of Major League Baseball Featuring Ken Griffey Jr., The Show flirts exceptionally close to baseball perfection.
User score
Mixed or Average
66% Positive
35 Ratings
35 Ratings
13% Mixed
7 Ratings
7 Ratings
21% Negative
11 Ratings
11 Ratings
Jun 25, 2024
10
I have to simply say this. This game was one of the greatest gaming presentations I have ever seen for a sports game, from the audio, the bat cracking sounds, the crowd booing you in their state, and even the commentary team as they react heavily towards your play, making villain decisions that can piss them off hard. I could go about the many other features that are in the game such as in game highlights, stat overlays and replays, and visually, could see players react realistically. For my final verdict: MLB 10: The Show was and still is a fantastic video game that successfully replicated everything that you and I love about baseball. If I could pick a PS3 sports game to play for the rest of my life, I’d be more than satisfied with this game. Best gameplay, best franchise depth, and best presentation, help deliver us one of the greatest sports video games of all time. This game transports you to a era where Sony was aiming to surpass Microsoft’s Xbox 360 and destroy 2K by releasing the best possible exclusive MLB year after year, and it was not just a great baseball game for PS3, not just the best sports game for the console, but one of the BEST PlayStation 3 games of all time in general. That statement is why I give MLB 10 a fitting rating of a 10 out of 10! Just a masterpiece that Sony can’t top ever again.
May 25, 2020
10
Last original game with legend teams, sadly this has been taken out of the newer games until much more recently and for that reason it adds a lot more depth then the games from 2011 to 2018 in my opinion
91
MLB 10: The Show is a well made game. I recommend this title if you love baseball; everyone else can find something different to play. The initial difficulty can be frustrating but a complex and rewarding game can be found just beneath the surface.
90
The depth, the possibilities and the realism make this a must have purchase for those interested in baseball. A title that truly rewards those who commit themselves to the game.
90
In the spirit of your favorite old-school fighting games, MLB 10 The Show is spectacular – and spectacularly mean.
85
While MLB 10 The Show remains the best baseball videogame money can buy, it’s no longer light-years ahead of 2K Sports’ effort. Is it better than MLB 09? Definitely, but not by a wide margin.
75
Sony still offers the superior baseball experience, but I actually enjoyed certain aspects of 2K10 a little bit more; unlike last year, this is no Yankees-Royals mismatch.
Jan 22, 2011
10
I still play this game on a regular basis and I got it right when it came out. Heck if you count the show 09 Ive been playing this series for about about 22 months in a row. This was the only reason I wanted a ps3 and Its been totally worth it. Cannot wait for the next version. At least the mets win the WS in my reality.
Nov 19, 2010
10
I have to be honest here,I love basketball and **** 2k11 I thought was the best sports game ever and it is true except for Mlb 10 the show.I know the two are completely different games entirely but after playing both for a very long time I will crown this game the king of sports games.This game is utterly amazing in every way possible to the point were now I don't want to play any of my other baseball games and I have just about every one that has came out on all systems.When I was younger I used to play Hard ball for the commodore 64 and I loved that game but basically this game is so good it has ruined all other baseball games and one that I don't believe will be topped at least in the next five years.Unless Sony has another trick up there sleeve,what a game!
Nov 18, 2022
9
Solid game and it's really fun to play franchise mode. It's hard to hit at times if you don't have a stacked team.
Sep 8, 2019
0
Somehow even worse than the previous release and a new leader for the worst game of all time.
Oct 16, 2012
0
This game I think is not so good the pitching ****, where you go to pitch it it doesn't go. Also when you go to hit the ball the best way is the power swing which is the square button because when you hit X on good balls they won't swing all the way they stop and strike you out. Also if you have the runners on auto they try to steal the base when t he ball is to close to the catchers and they end up getting you out. Overall this game ****.
SummaryMLB 10 The Show NEW Features: HR Derby – The Home Run Derby and MLB All-Star Futures Game are now available during the All-Star break in our season modes and as a stand-alone experience. Catcher Calling the Game – Call pitches and play as the field general, just like Joe Mauer. Online Gameplay Improved – This year the online gameplay exp... Read More
Rated Efor Everyone
