Tim Goodman
Critic Overview in TV Shows
64Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
616(58%)
mixed
241(23%)
negative
208(20%)
Highest Critic Score
Lowest Critic Score
Critic Reviews for TV Shows
Jan 13, 2026
Da Ali G Show (US): Season 150
Jan 13, 2026
There's no question that Sacha Baron Cohen is talented. And it may prove unwise to discount the tremendous popularity he and his Ali G character achieved in the United Kingdom. But the concept is hardly original to an American audience and, unfortunately, plays well under the acceptable level of greatness we've all come to expect from HBO. [21 Feb 2003]
Dec 2, 2021
Back: Season 1100
Dec 2, 2021
Back is one of the funniest and most intriguingly different comedies in a long time. ... it's Blackwell's intelligent and searing writing--which also has quite a bit of emotional nuance--that makes Back much more than mere joke creation for its own sake. And it's Mitchell and Webb who make it all come to life, with Mitchell's virtuoso performance as the increasingly paranoid Stephen shining through all six episodes.
May 14, 2021
Salem's Lot (2004): Season 125
May 14, 2021
Terrible...The first five minutes of Salem's Lot are great. Well, four minutes. And then Lowe's voice-over kicks in, which essentially starts the poison drip. It's a lot of King-speak, which is annoying and so formulaic it ought to be patented (and might be). There's a line about "dull, mindless, moronic evil," which is pretty much a perfect synopsis of the movie.
May 11, 2021
Storm of the Century: Season 150
May 11, 2021
It's edge-of-the-couch good in some spots. The trouble is that it has too many spots. So many that the title should have been changed to "Story That Lasts a Century." When you're done with all six hours of "Storm" you'll be exhausted. And if you're not one of King's rabid fans who will forgive him anything, you'll have a similar thought: "Gee, that was pretty good. Could have done it in two hours, but I'll live."
Apr 13, 2021
Kingdom Hospital: Season 125
Apr 13, 2021
Based on the two-hour premiere, a hodgepodge of false dramatic starts, bad acting, rambling scenes, a stupendously annoying narrator and a metaphorical anteater that looks like, of all things, ALF, there's only one conclusion to draw: Those things aren't scary. They're stupid.
Dec 16, 2019
Falcone: Season 170
Dec 16, 2019
The show is good but not great. It feels redundant because it is - two times over, if you count the movie. There's no denying that's a huge drawback, no matter how brooding Gedrick and Welliver get. And, from a pure entertainment stand point, it's less satisfying to see Falcone's wife and family implode than it is to see what's happening with Tony Soprano's home life. Sorry, but it's true.
Nov 11, 2019
Dublin Murders: Season 130
Nov 11, 2019
Dublin Murders [is] a mess and, in parts, preposterous. Having watched all eight episodes knowing that an intricate (OK, fine, farfetched) set of plot points wouldn’t come together until, at the earliest, the seventh episode, I'll just tell you (since we're still in the Peak TV era with no signs of let-up): Don't bother.
Nov 5, 2019
Back to Life: Season 1100
Nov 5, 2019
A wonderfully nuanced story that's both extremely funny and tragically sad, but never leans too hard in either direction to get a reaction. It just exists and, after six episodes, it ends — and when it does you get the full appreciation of how exceptional it is. ... Back to Life is a real, unexpected gem of a series and one of the better surprises of 2019.
Nov 5, 2019
The End of the F***ing World: Season 280
Nov 5, 2019
The good news is that season two of The End of the F***ing World stays true to the vibe of the first season, has a decently good but not great story and manages, by the end of the final episode (of eight in total), to have righted most of the wrongs that came before it.
Nov 1, 2019
Tom Clancy's Jack Ryan: Season 270
Nov 1, 2019
Jack Ryan is still fun, despite being a little bit ridiculous and predictable.