JustWatch
Advertisement

Matthew Gilbert

Critic Overview in TV Shows
62Avg. Critic Score
Critic Score Distribution
positive
767(54%)
mixed
470(33%)
negative
193(13%)
Lowest Critic Score

Critic Reviews for TV Shows

Jan 14, 2026
Da Ali G Show (US): Season 1
63
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
Jan 14, 2026
Despite Cohen's talent for submerging himself in his characters, "Da Ali G Show" is a spotty venture. [22 Feb 2003]
Jun 27, 2024
The Bear: Season 3
80
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
Jun 27, 2024
The bottom line is that the characters haven’t been magically healed between seasons, as they are on some shows; these folks are still wrestling with the same decisions, with old wounds, with one another, and, when all is said and done, with creating a perfect dining experience.
Jun 18, 2024
House of the Dragon: Season 2
60
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
Jun 18, 2024
I’m having mixed feelings. .... The show remains highly watchable, and it mostly supports its status as a Sunday night ritual, where battles rage, dragons swoop and soar, white hair blows, and the palace drama stays at a solid boil. .... But the absence of Paddy Considine as King Viserys leaves a large hole, as he was one of only a few acting heavyweights in the mix. .... Matt Smith, who added so much sly ambiguity to the first season, is largely MIA, as his Daemon goes off on a side trip to a decaying castle.
Jun 12, 2024
Presumed Innocent: Season 1
70
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
Jun 12, 2024
“Presumed Innocent” — two episodes are currently available, with new episodes arriving on Wednesdays — remains a solid beach read of a whodunit. Apple TV+, which premiered the series on Wednesday, did not provide critics with the final episode, and I still don’t feel sure of who committed the crime — always a good sign.
Jun 6, 2024
Queenie: Season 1
80
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
Jun 6, 2024
I’m not sure the show, which was created by Carty-Williams, needs to bring us into therapy with Queenie; like the voiceover, it feels a bit like a cheat, a way to spell out her issues rather than simply show them. But it’s far from a deal-breaker. Brown carries the show with a strong realism and a quiet reactivity.
May 29, 2024
Eric: Season 1
60
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
May 29, 2024
The acting in the Netflix miniseries “Eric” is knock-down-drag-out good. There’s anger, madness, fear, loss, and grief all over the script, and there’s a set of performers, most notably Benedict Cumberbatch, who are seriously up to the task. Emotion is discharged. It’s all in service of an unwieldy, overstuffed 1980s-set story line that’s too ambitious for its own good, alas — but still, there’s a lot to admire in these six fast-paced episodes.
May 28, 2024
Bodkin: Season 1
50
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
May 28, 2024
One of the big problems with “Bodkin” is that it hardly adds up to much. All of the investigation goes to some absurd places, and I don’t think that was intentional. And there are plot holes galore along the way. The denouement, incomplete and hard to believe, may test your patience.
May 23, 2024
Interview With the Vampire: Season 2
100
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
May 23, 2024
It remains a supernatural gem. The AMC series is as good as it was in season 1, as it continues to capture the despair, the anarchy, and the raw power of being immortal. .... And the acting is uniformly excellent.
May 22, 2024
Bridgerton: Season 3
80
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
May 22, 2024
It’s all sumptuous fun. The spectacular balls with the orchestrated pop songs and the old-old-old-school line-dancing continue to dazzle. The supporting characters, including Lady Danbury (the fabulous Adjoa Andoh), her newly returned brother Marcus (Daniel Francis), and mean girl Cressida (Jessica Madsen), continue to amuse.
May 21, 2024
Hacks: Season 3
90
Critic ScoreMatthew Gilbert
May 21, 2024
“Hacks” remains thoroughly enjoyable. .... Their [Deborah and Ava's] evolved dynamic has helped to make season 3 a joy. The show has a new warmth, and something to root for.
Advertisement
Related Content: ijumpman | fishie fishie | lucha libre aaa heroes del ring | disgaea 4 a promise unforgotten medic | disgaea 4 a promise unforgotten pirohiko ichimonji | four in a row 2010 | zombie square | super sniper hd | the will of dr frankenstein | chuck e cheeseand39s party games alley roller